May 4, 2017 / Riskline Informer

The THAAD conundrum

Predicting Seoul’s next steps ahead of the 9 May South Korean presidential election.

On 10 March, months of mass protests across South Korea culminated in a unanimous 8-0 Constitutional Court ruling confirming the impeachment of then-President Park Geun-hye. While the upcoming 9 May presidential election is seen as a triumph for millions who demanded her ouster, it also coincides with a security challenge that has spiralled in Park’s absence. The next president must decide on the fate of the United States’s Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) missile defence system. With Washington promising that THAAD will protect South Korea from North Korean missile attacks, and Beijing claiming it will be used to track missiles deployed in northeastern China, the question of its deployment is the latest dilemma to emerge from the tangled security dynamics of the Korean peninsula.

The odds in the presidential race favour Moon Jae-in of the liberal Democratic Party. Moon has spoken in favour of standing up to Washington and of greater autonomy over South Korea’s defence. Polling at 40 percent, Moon enjoys a formidable 20 percent lead over the centrist People’s Party candidate Ahn Cheol-soo. A Moon victory would end ten years of conservative rule that responded to North Korean provocation through closer alignment with the United States (US). Seoul would likely attempt to take its first step away from Washington through renewed resistance to THAAD.

If and when Moon takes office, the US may hope that its actions in Park’s absence exerted enough pressure to finalise the deployment. In an unannounced move, US forces delivered THAAD components to its installment site at Lotte Skyhill Country Club in Seongju overnight on 26 April, a month after it first began shipping components and shortly before Park’s impeachment. The surprise move ensured that THAAD will be at operational stages by 9 May, leaving Seoul little time to reconsider deployment of the defensive system despite economic pressure from China, including an ongoing tourism ban and a boycott of South Korean products.

So far, Moon has refused to condemn THAAD outright, taking a stance dubbed ‘strategic ambiguity’. Unlike his fellow Democratic Party members, he refused to rule out any possibilities, going as far as to acknowledge that the deployment may be inevitable in the event of further North Korean nuclear provocations, including a sixth nuclear test. Instead, he has called for renewed negotiations on THAAD emplacement. In the days following the surprise operation on 26 April, clues on how these discussions will unfold have emerged.

After the unannounced US delivery in April, Washington reopened the debate in another surprise move. US President Donald Trump demanded on two separate occasions that Seoul pay for the deployment, which he valued at one billion USD. After initially appearing to contradict him, US National Security Advisor Herbert McMaster confirmed not only Washington’s interest in renegotiation, but that this renegotiation would involve a push to increase Seoul’s budget share for US forces stationed in South Korea, effectively putting the security relationship between the two countries on the table. While prospects of paying for THAAD and increasing the budget for US forces share have already triggered public backlash in South Korea, renewed security negotiations also carry the potential of diminished US military involvement in South Korea, allowing Seoul greater autonomy over its security agenda.

Another likely venue for discussion will be the National Assembly, where Moon’s Democratic Party and the progressive Justice Party hold a majority of seats. In a 28 April debate, Moon claimed the issue of THAAD costs would be subject to National Assembly ratification. Days later, his party vowed to hold hearings on the May deployment. With the US reopening the question of THAAD and seeking to discuss broader US-South Korea security dynamics, further public debates and parliamentary votes may be held to shape Seoul’s security policy agenda in this process. Regardless of the outcome, renewed discussions may delay THAAD in its final stages and show Seoul demanding greater say on its security relationship with Washington than it did under conservative leadership.

The THAAD conundrum underscores South Korea’s tangled security dynamics, where Seoul struggles with Beijing and Washington’s conflicting interests. Like many of South Korea’s security challenges, the THAAD deployment will leave the incoming administration grappling with a question that will cause domestic and international opposition to any answer. In the event of Moon Jae-in’s victory on 9 May, that resistance will likely come from the US, as Seoul and Washington’s security agenda diverges in the new administration’s quest for greater autonomy.

Riskline Travel Search API
Vital information for trip booking with Travel Search API
Share This
Continue Reading

Travellers are safer when they stay informed

Riskline Alert Messaging operates all day, every day. Each alert contains essential intelligence, practical advice and precise geographic data about risks to traveller safety or impacts on travel plans. When we are able to get advanced warning, notices are also issued for events happening in the future.
Riskline Informer
Keep informed of key developments around the world.

Get prepared before you travel

Riskline Pre-Travel Advisories (PTAs) are exactly what a traveller needs to know about their destination before they leave home. Each report is a concise summary of the security and travel safety situation for any destination, and can be sent straight to travellers’ emails.

Let our experts show you how Riskline can keep you informed.

Everything your travellers need to know before they travel

Riskline’s TravelPrep provides important safety information directly to travellers, empowering them to travel safer and smarter.
Let our experts show you how Riskline can keep you informed.

Risk ratings you can build a travel policy around

Riskline has detailed assessments for more than 225 countries and territories around the world. Each report has an easy-to-understand Risk Level™ that can be integrated into travel policies and other business operations. Risk assessments include an overview of the security and travel safety situation in a country, and detailed analysis of the political, terrorism, conflict, unrest, crime, natural, health and local transport risks.
Let our experts show you how Riskline can keep you informed.

Know more about where you actually go

We assess the safety of more than 250 global cities, assigning each a clear Risk Level. In addition to city-specific threats and other local knowledge, every report has a map of important locations down to street level.
Use Cases
See how our City Safety Reports can help keep your travellers safe.

People make better decisions when they have the full picture

Advisories are detailed assessments of ongoing security situations and travel issues. We publish reports for high-risk geographic areas, political and security crises, persisting travel disruptions and major upcoming events, such as elections and international sporting competitions.
Let our experts show you how Riskline can keep you informed.

Covid-19 travel advice at your fingertips

Don’t let COVID-19 confusion get in the way of your customers’ decisions. Give them a tool at their fingertips that lets them see the implications of Covid on their travel plans and how best to prepare for their trip. TravelCheck displays up to date risk and infection scores, at-a-glance information on their destination and need-to-know information on departure, in-flight and arrival.

It’s easy to customise your widget with your own brand colour and poster image, to seamlessly integrate it into your website.

Our simple Javascript installation will get you up and running in no time. A few lines of code is all it takes to install the widget, with 2 display modes available – inline for embedding into a single page, or modal for a floating, site-wide travel assistant.

Interested in trying our TravelCheck widget? Get in touch.

Helping travellers manage Covid-19 disruptions

We have closely tracked developments associated with COVID-19 since late 2019, gathering detailed information on entry and exit requirements, You can get our real-time COVID-19 intelligence via alerts, API, microsite, and the TravelCheck widget.
Let our experts show you how Riskline can keep you informed.

The right guidance for specific needs

Not all travellers are the same. Riskline’s Specific Traveller Advice includes country-specific information tailored for LGBTQ+ travellers, female travellers and tech-dependent travellers.

Riskline Informer
Keep informed of key developments around the world.

Keep Informed

Get the latest Riskline Informer news delivered to your inbox.